40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Review

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50
Orca Cooler Sizes vs Yeti Cooler Sizes

If you’re on the market for an ultra-durable roto molded cooler, Orcas and Tundras are both great choices. In the second part of our “Orca Cooler Sizes vs Yeti Cooler Sizes Series,” we’ll tackle the 40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler Comparison.

Overview & Navigation
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

At Chuggie, our mission is to give you all the information you need to make an informed decision. Because of that, our cooler reviews include important aspects such as:

Orca Cooler Colors

True Capacity, Weight, and Dimensions
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler Comparison
Orca Cooler Sizes vs Yeti Cooler Sizes

  • Of course, true capacity varies among different brands of high end ice chests. Another key point is that Yeti doesn’t use numbers to claim capacity.
  • Instead, the numbers represent the “Series Number.”
  • Since the Orca 40 Quart and the Yeti Tundra 50 are closest in capacity, they’re a good fit for a side-by-side cooler comparison.

Actual Capacity, Weight, and Dimensions of the Yeti Tundra 50

Cooler Comparison Yeti Cooler Review Dimensions

True Capacity: 47.2 quarts
Exterior Dimensions: L: 18 1/8″ X W: 24″ x H: 17 3/8″
Interior Dimensions: L: 12 1/8″ X W: 5/8 X H: 10 5/8″
Weight: 26 lbs

Actual Capacity, Weight, and Dimensions of the Orca 40 Quart

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

True Capacity: 40 quart
Exterior Dimensions: L: 26″ X W: 17.5″ X H: 17.5″
Interior Dimensions: L: 19″ X W: 11.75″ X H: 11″
Weight: 24 lbs

Go Back To Overview

Construction
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

Both of these rugged molded coolers have fantastic construction. But in the 40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 standoff, how do they compare? First, we’ll look at Yeti’s construction.

Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler Construction

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50
Your Yeti Tundra 50 will come with a dry goods basket, whereas an Orca will now. (Click for Pictures)

1. Marine-grade rope handles (except the Yeti Roadie)
2. Rubber handle
3. Detachable drain plug; you can remove it completely to drain quickly or partially open it
halfway to control the flow

4. Removable dry goods basket included in the price of the cooler (except the Yeti Roadie)
5. Rail handles

6. “T-Rex” Rubber Latches
7. Slip-Resistant Feet
8. Rotomolded with integrated insulation
9. Riveted pin system
10. Rubber gasket

Orca 40 Quart Cooler Construction

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50
Here you can see the Orca 40 qt’s mesh pocket. (Amazon link)

1. Durable nylon cord handles with a rubber grip point
2. “Whale Tail” rubber latches
3. Dry goods baskets are not included in the price
4. Molded in handles
5. Somewhat slippery feet (solve this with a slip resistant pad)
6. Roto molded with integrated insulation
7. Pin system for hinges
8. Built-in cargo pocket
9. Rubber gasket
10. Detachable drain plug
Go Back to Overview

 

3 Differences in Construction to Be Aware Of

As you can see, both of these mighty beasts are constructed in similar ways, with just a few slight differences. The differences include:

  • Orca Coolers have thicker insulation, which translates to better ice retention.
  • They also have more dry storage space with their cargo net pockets.
  • Yeti’s drain plugs have a hole in them, while the Orca’s do not.

2 Very Small Differences in Construction

    • Yeti’s “T-Rex” latches are almost exactly the same as the Orca’s “Whale Tail” latches. They’re both high quality and function the same way.
    • Lastly, their handles are made from different materials. However, they’re both tough cords with rubber grips. They work the same way to help two people distribute the weight evenly as they carry the ice chest.

Video #1: YETI Coolers vs Slingshot

Go Back To Overview

Durability

As the video demonstrates, the Yeti Tundra will handle anything life throws at it! Now, to see how it compares to the Orca 40 Quart.

The 4 Ultra-Strong Characteristics of the 40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

  1. The plastic that makes up their body and lid, which is called “polyethylene,” is their secret weapon.
  2. Also, the riveted pin system keeps their hinges right where they belong.
  3. Finally, rotomolded pieces of equipment are among the strongest in the world. For detailed information about the various types of plastic, go here 
  4. Another similarity is that they’re both Certified Grizzly Bear proof.

Just take a look at the videos of Grizzly Bears attempting to open both Orca and Yeti Coolers. Spoiler alert: the bears fail miserably.

Go Back To Overview

The 40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50
Why They Both Have the Same Level of Usability

There are several similarities in how these coolers are user-friendly…and how they aren’t. First, here are the similarities:

Orca 40 Quart vs Yeti Tundra 50
Here’s a good look at the Orca 40 Quart’s handles.
  • Both coolers’ lids *may* snap shut unexpectedly, according to some owner reviews.
  • Another shared feature is their nylon rope handles; these make two-person carrying easier.
  • They both tend to be quite heavy compared to other high end ice chests.

Now for the differences:

  • Although both coolers have screw-on, detachable drain plugs, we prefer the Yeti’s plug.
  • A Yeti drain plug has a hole on the screw-on part, so you can partially unscrew it to slow down the water flow. 
  • It’s easier to store small items you want to keep dry in the Orca, since it has a side mesh pocket.
  • Lastly, Orca Cooler’s feet can be slippery on wet surfaces, like on a boat.

The pros and cons of each brand of ice chest weigh each other out. Therefore, it makes the most sense to call it a tie.
Go Back to Overview

Ice Retention
40 Quart Orca Cooler vs Yeti Tundra 50

On average, the Orca 40 Quart will hold ice for at least two days longer than a Yeti Tundra 50. No matter which cooler you choose to buy, it ultimately depends on many factors. (Such as pre-cooling, ice packs vs ice, ambient temperature, etc.)

Although the “20 Quart Orca vs Yeti Roadie Cooler Comparison Video” below is between different cooler sizes, it does a great job of showing how well Orca Coolers hold ice. 

*A key point in this ice test challenge is that the Yeti Roadie had an advantage of being pre-cooled longer. But it still lost the ice chest challenge.

>>The Utimate Review of the Best, Long Lasting Ice Packs<<

 

Accessories
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

Yeti Tundra 50’s Accessories: The Top 6

Yeti Coolers accessory collection is as wide and varied as Orca Cooler accessories:

Cooler Comparison
And of course, Yeti Ice.

Go Back to Overview

Orca 40 Quart’s Accessories

Although each of these high end cooler brands offer fantastic accessories, Orca blows Yeti out of the water with their molle wrap system.

Overall, it’s the Orca Gear Molle System that reigns supreme. This molle system will securely hold:

Orca Molle Attachment
This is a MUST for outdoors people.
  • Cell phone
  • First Aid Kit
  • Flashlight Holder
  • Pistol Holder
  • Hybrid System Solar Panel
  • Shot Shell Holder
  • Quad Mag Holder
  • Mini tac-vest koozie

Dry Ice Compatibility
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler Comparison

Using Dry Ice in 40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

Both of these high end rotomolded coolers are 100% dry ice compatible! In fact, they’re two of the best ice chests for using with dry ice.

Using dry ice will keep your contents frozen, which is great for fishing and hunting weekends. For tips and more info about using dry ice in your cooler, check out “How Long Does Dry Ice Last in a Cooler?”

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50
Find out how to use dry ice, how long it lasts, and everything in between.

Go Back To Overview

Where Are They Made?
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

Where are Yeti Coolers made?

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50,Orca cooler sizes vs yeti cooler sizes, orca vs yeti, yeti vs, cooler comparison, best cooler reviews, yeti tundra 50 cooler, Orca 40 quart Review

It’s a myth that Yeti Coolers are 100% American-made. Sure, their head quarters are in Texas. And Yeti manufactures some of their coolers in Wisconsin and Iowa. But they also have large factories in the Philippines where most of the manufacturing occurs.

You can give Yeti a call and request a 100% American-made product. (Contact Yeti Customer Service at 512.394.9384 to request a Yeti made only on USA soil.)

Where are Orca Coolers made?

In contrast, Orca Ice Chests are made, produced, and manufactured in the good ol’ USA. (Orca Podsters and Orca Chasers are not.)

Go Back To Overview

Price
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

40 qt Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler Comparison
(Click for more Pictures/Discounts)

Each cooler costs about the same.

Usually, you can find an Orca 40 Quart Cooler for a little less than a Yeti Tundra 50. However, the differences in price are small.

So, in the “40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Review,” this is a tie. These are two of the best coolers on the market today.

They’re both worth the investment!

Go Back To Overview

 

Warranty
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50

  • Yeti Tundra 50 Warranty: 5 Years
  • Orca 40 Quart Warranty: Lifetime

Colors, Patterns, & Collegiate Designs

40 Quart Orca vs Yeti 50
Follow the link for the 63 other Yeti Tundra Collegiate Coolers!

#1. 40 Quart Orca Cooler vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler “Classic Colors” 

Since both brands offer different categories of colors and designs, we’ll break it down for an easier comparison. First, each brand offers a “classic” color selection.

Yeti Tundra 50’s Classic Colors

The Yeti Tundra 50 quart cooler comes in 3 classic colors: Desert Tan, White, and Ice Blue.

Orca 40 Quart’s 8 Classic Colors

In contrast, the Orca 40 qt cooler has 8 colors to choose from: Pink, Green, Navy, Black, Pink, Light Blue, Seafoam, and White.

Yeti Cooler Sizes vs Yeti Cooler Sizes
The 8 classic Orca Cooler colors.

#2. 40 Quart Orca Cooler vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler “Collegiate Coolers”

Orca 40 Quart’s Collegiate Coolers & Tumblers

40 Quart Orca Cooler vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler
Orca’s tumbler cups are just as colorful as their coolers!

In Orca’s collection of high end rotomolded coolers, there are 17 Collegiate Coolers. If you visit Orca’s website, you’ll find them.

Yeti Tundra 50’s Collegiate Coolers & Tumblers

Now it’s Yeti’s time to shine, since they offer a whopping 64 different Collegiate Coolers!

Additionally, they offer their Rambler Tumbler Cups with a selection of 64 college’s symbols on the front side. Unlike the Collegiate Coolers, you’ll need to buy these direction from Yeti’s website.

Go Back To Overview

>>Customize Cheaply<<

So, which cooler is right for you?
40 Quart Orca vs Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler

If you’re willing to make an investment, we believe the Orca 40 Quart is the best cooler for the money.

It has the same great features as the Yeti Tundra 50 Cooler, but also has better qualities:

  1. Lifetime Warranty
  2. Better Ice Retention
  3. Color Availability
  4. Made 100% in the U.S.

However, we also think you’d be happy purchasing a Yeti Tundra Cooler. It isn’t as though you’d buy a Yeti Cooler and find yourself shaking your head thinking, “I sure am disappointed in my Yeti.”

We just think the Orca is better. Happy Trails!

Readers who enjoyed “Orca Cooler Sizes vs Yeti Cooler Sizes, Orca 40 vs Yeti Tundra 50” also read:

>>20 Quart Orca vs Yeti Roadie, Cooler Comparison Review<<
>>Pelican Coolers vs Yeti Coolers<<



Go Back To Overview

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get 15% OFF your first order
You will not receive this offer again, seriously.
Check your email for the coupon code.
We respect your privacy, we will never spam you.