Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Overview
The Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers faceoff differs significantly from our previous cooler comparisons. Coleman Xtreme Coolers are much cheaper than the coolers we’ve discussed so far. In fact, they’re considered “low-end” coolers. On the other hand, Yeti and most of the other brands reviewed are “high-end” coolers.
We’ve set out to determine whether or not the low prices of Coleman Xtreme Coolers equal poor quality. Our approach is open-minded; maybe the expensive coolers have been duping us all along. While considering the coolers, we focused on price, ice retention, durability, and ease of use.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Price
The price point is the most obvious difference between the two. You can buy a Coleman 52qt Xtreme Cooler for $38-$50 on Amazon.
A Yeti 65 Series Cooler costs about $400 and holds just five more quarts than the Coleman 52qt Xtreme Cooler.
In the Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers battle, Coleman is the clear winner. If you’re on a tight budget, this is probably just the cooler for you.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Coleman Xtreme Coolers & Ice Retention
Many customer-performed home tests show that Coleman Xtreme Coolers hold ice longer than the costlier brand of Grizzly Hunting Coolers. And almost all the user reviews we discovered declared the Coleman Xtreme Cooler’s victory over others in its class, like Rubbermaid and Igloo Coolers.
Although these tests aren’t directly related to the Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers comparison, they do give us confidence in their ability. Coleman claims that their coolers hold ice for five days. This stands true in multiple home tests and user reviews.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers’ sturdy walls and notably thick lids are the biggest contributors to their ability to hold ice. A disadvantage is their lack of a gasket.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers are ideal for making your weekends just that much better. Going for a day trip to the beach? Coleman has you covered. They’ll chill your snacks and icy cold drinks to perfection. Your snacks and icy cold drinks will be chilled to perfection. There’s hardly anything better than a refreshing can of beer when you’re hunkering down under the hot sun for hours on end.
And if you need to use the cooler for a longer amount of time, like on road trips or while camping within a campground, a Coleman Xtreme Cooler is great. You can pick up ice and replenish your trusty ice chest as needed. It’s exceptionally easy to drain, making the empty and refill process easy as pie.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Yeti Coolers & Ice Retention
Yeti Coolers are roto-molded with thick walls and heavy duty insulation. Yeti doesn’t provide any claim for how long their coolers will keep ice cold. But in home tests, Yeti Coolers typically hold ice from between five to seven days.
Yeti-owners swear that these hefty coolers’ ice lasts well beyond seven days. They’ve compared their coolers’ performances against those of their camping buddies. These loyal aficionados have seen the evidence. Yeti Cooler die-hards seem to find their Yeti superior in every way, so we know who they’d choose as the best cooler in the Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers comparison.
Coleman Xtreme Cooler vs Yeti Coolers: Which has better ice retention?
It’s a tie, folks. The simple answer is Yeti Coolers. But this Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers really isn’t a fair competition – it’s like comparing apples to oranges.
The two coolers have entirely different purposes. Yeti Coolers hold ice for a longer period, making them a great option for longer, more rugged adventures.
The Coleman Xtreme Cooler isn’t made with rugged outdoorsy trips in mind. It’s an excellent choice for shorter events such as parties on the patio or a night of drinking around the fire pit in your backyard.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Durability
Coleman Xtreme Coolers again score better than other brands of low-end coolers, like Rubbermaid. Their tough “Have-a-Seat” lids can support up to 250lbs and their rigid walls are strong enough to withstand some day-to-day wear and tear.
It’s likely that your Coleman Xtreme Cooler’s handles and hinges will fall apart at some point. Fortunately, you can find replacement parts at unbelievably low prices. Coleman replacement hinges and screw are available an Amazon for only $5.35. Amazon also offers handle replacements for as low as $9.99.
In comparison, Yeti Coolers have longer-lasting hinges, bases, and lids. They’re also grizzly bear resilient, roto-molded, and have protective stainless steel. Riveted pins running along the inner part of the frame safeguards their state-of-the-art latch hardware. his locking pin arrangement keeps the latches and other hardware securely connected to the body of the cooler.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Which has better durability?
Yeti Coolers are more durable. But really, it’s all about what you plan to do with your cooler.
We don’t recommend taking a Coleman Xtreme Cooler with you on a hardcore weekend or week(s) of hiking or camping out in the wild. A cooler used for gentler activities doesn’t need to be as heavy duty. It’s unlikely that you’re going to see a hungry grizzly bear jogging along the shoreline of the local beach, dodging sandcastles and stray beach balls.
Yeti Coolers are the heartier of the two. They’re made for rugged adventures and can withstand plenty of wear and tear for decades. Choosing to buy the Yeti is an excellent decision for a variety of high-impact outdoor activities throughout the years. But why would you spend a few hundred dollars more on a high-end cooler when a low-end cooler is perfectly suited to fit your needs? Coleman Xtreme Coolers reliably hold ice for five days.
Declaring a clear winner and loser in the durability section of the Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers is like comparing apples to oranges. These coolers aren’t intended to compete with each other!
Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Ease of Use
Users of the Coleman Xtreme Coolers rave about the simple and easy-to-use drain plug. It’s easy to open, consistently drains at the same pace, and won’t cause a huge watery mess. Yeti Coolers can be pesky to drain, as their handles dangle at the exact level of the drain plug. Often, the drain plug spews out water when first opened, making for a messy situation.
The lids in both of the coolers have their own quirks. Definitely expect the Coleman Xtreme Cooler’s lid to leak. This isn’t a huge deal, because most coolers, including the Yeti, slosh out water from time to time. The Yeti Cooler’s quirk is that its lid has a mind of its own. It sporadically snaps shut.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers are lighter and therefore easily carried. Customers report discomfort from their handles, but other dislike the Yeti’s handles…and, well, pretty much about every cooler.
So, for the ease of use portion of Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers, the Coleman Xtreme Coolers come out on top.
Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Final Thoughts
They’re both winners – depending on what you need in a cooler. In fact, the “vs” in Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers comparison might as well be switched to an “and/or.”
Go for the Coleman Xtreme Cooler, if you’re not interested in long, heavy-duty camping, hunting, or fishing trips. A Coleman Xtreme Cooler may be your best bet, if you’re not going to be away from an ice source for long. Coleman Xtreme Coolers are ideal for your brief, but oh-so-relaxing weekend ventures.
Buy an ultra-tough Yeti Cooler for more intense ventures. You won’t be disappointed – nearly all customers give it a five star rating.
We stand by our title, Coleman Xtreme Coolers vs Yeti Coolers: Apples and Oranges? It’s not a battle but rather a comparison of ice chests intended for such different purposes that it’s like comparing apples to oranges.
Choose which one fits your budget and vacation style, and the best cooler for you will become crystal clear.